Bosnia's Constitutional Court Finds RS entity Provision on Army of RBiH Symbols unconstitutional, overturns Cvijanovic's veto

The Constitutional Court of Bosnia and Herzegovina has ruled that a provision of Republika Srpska's Criminal Code criminalising the public display of symbols associated with the Army of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina is unconstitutional. The Court also invalidated a declaration by Presidency member Zeljka Cvijanovic invoking the vital interests of Republika Srpska, along with a decision by the entity's National Assembly endorsing it.
The rulings were among the decisions adopted at the Court's 176th plenary session, held on November 19 and 20, 2026, according to an official statement issued on Friday.
Provision concerning Army of RBiH symbols found unconstitutional
In case U-20/26, the Constitutional Court examined requests submitted by 11 members of the House of Representatives of Bosnia and Herzegovina's Parliamentary Assembly, Denis Becirovic and Denis Zvizdic.
The requests challenged Article 359b of the Criminal Code of Republika Srpska, which criminalised the public display, exhibition, wearing, production, reproduction or distribution of flags, symbols, insignia, greetings and slogans promoting or glorifying the Army of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina (ARBiH).
The Court found that the provision was incompatible with Articles I(2) and III(3)(b) of the Constitution of Bosnia and Herzegovina.
In its reasoning, the Court emphasised that regulations adopted by the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina governing the appearance and use of ARBiH symbols and insignia remain in force throughout the country under the constitutional principle of legal continuity.
It also concluded that the National Assembly of Republika Srpska has no authority to determine the termination of legal acts adopted by institutions of the Republic of Bosnia and Herzegovina whose continuity is constitutionally recognised.
The Court further noted that, under decisions adopted by state institutions, the ARBiH forms part of the Armed Forces of Bosnia and Herzegovina through its military heritage, identity and distinctive insignia.
The display of those insignia is a duty of the relevant infantry regiments, according to the Court's statement.
The judges concluded that the disputed provision violated the constitutional hierarchy of legal norms and conflicted with decisions adopted by Bosnia and Herzegovina's institutions.
Court invalidates Cvijanovic's declaration and RS National Assembly decision
In case U-17/26, the Constitutional Court ruled on a request submitted by Denis Becirovic, who was serving as Chair of the Presidency of Bosnia and Herzegovina when the request was filed.
The dispute concerned a declaration issued by Presidency member Zeljka Cvijanovic on July 1, 2026, stating that a Presidency decision appointing members of the Commission to Preserve National Monuments was highly detrimental to the vital interests of Republika Srpska.
The Presidency had adopted the appointments on June 29 without consensus.
On July 7, the National Assembly of Republika Srpska adopted a decision endorsing Cvijanovic's declaration.
The Constitutional Court found that both acts were incompatible with Article V(2)(d) of Bosnia and Herzegovina's Constitution.
It concluded that the declaration and the Assembly's decision had been adopted contrary to the constitutional requirements set out in that provision and invalidated both in their entirety.
As a result, the Presidency's June 29 decision appointing members of the Commission to Preserve National Monuments remains legally valid.
Court upholds constitutional provisions on vital national interests
In a separate case, U-16/22, the Constitutional Court examined a request submitted by Presidency member Zeljko Komsic challenging provisions of the constitutions of the Federation of Bosnia and Herzegovina and Republika Srpska governing the protection of vital national interests.
Komsic raised three principal objections.
First, he argued that citizens classified as "Others" were discriminated against because they could participate in majority decision-making in the relevant legislative bodies but could not invoke the mechanism for protecting vital national interests.
Second, he argued that the categories of vital national interests were defined too broadly, potentially allowing almost any issue to be treated as a threat to the interests of a constituent people.
Third, he questioned differences between legislative procedures in the two entities, particularly the role of the Federation's House of Peoples compared with the Council of Peoples in Republika Srpska.
The Court did not accept these constitutional objections.
It explained that the protection of vital national interests was not conceived as an individual right but as a mechanism designed to prevent one community from dominating another in societies characterised by significant differences.
Under this constitutional arrangement, the mechanism is linked to the constituent peoples forming the basis of the country's constitutional compromise.
The Court also acknowledged that the mechanism could be invoked in cases that did not genuinely concern the vital national interests of a constituent people.
However, it found that the possibility of misuse did not, in itself, make the mechanism unconstitutional, particularly given the oversight provided by the entities' constitutional courts.
Regarding differences between legislative procedures in the two entities, the Court found that these did not, on their own and in the circumstances of the request, establish discrimination.
The Court ultimately ruled that the challenged constitutional provisions were compatible with Bosnia and Herzegovina's Constitution and the relevant international human rights instruments.
It also stressed that responsibility for changing the existing constitutional system, should it no longer be considered appropriate more than three decades after the war, rested with the constitutional legislature rather than the Constitutional Court.
Violation of the right to a fair trial established
In case AP-4497/24, the Constitutional Court found a violation of the principle of legal certainty as an element of the right to a fair trial.
The case concerned a ruling by the Cantonal Court in Sarajevo, acting as the final judicial instance, that contradicted previous decisions involving the same or similar factual and legal circumstances without providing an objective and reasonable justification.
The Constitutional Court noted that the appellants had no effective legal remedy or mechanism available to ensure consistency in judicial practice.
It therefore found a violation of the right to a fair trial under Bosnia and Herzegovina's Constitution and Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
The Constitutional Court said all decisions adopted at the plenary session would be delivered to the applicants and appellants within one month and published on its official website as soon as possible.
Kakvo je tvoje mišljenje o ovome?
Učestvuj u diskusiji ili pročitaj komentare